Featured: Ask Your Team How They Want to Be Led


Communication Intelligence, an interview-driven newsletter, asked a group of leaders whether tailoring how you lead each person really earns buy-in. I was glad to add my voice to a lively mix of founders, an HR chief and a communication trainer, each coming at the question from a very different background.
Here’s the full article, shared with permission. My answers are in bold.
Personalization for Inspiring Employee Buy-In
Here is a discussion about the practicality and potential risks and benefits
By Michael Toebe, Communication Intelligence
People may have different motivations for doing their best work, regardless of circumstances. One leader chose a different approach with her employees with the expectation that it would develop understanding, drive higher performance, make her her job easier and produce stronger, collective, consistent performance.
It may have worked as Natalie Nakase, a head coach for the Golden State Valkyries in the Women’s National Basketball Association (WNBA), just led her team to a championship in the franchise’s second season of existence.
Brian Hamilton, writing at The Athletic for the New York Times, did a feature article on that rapid ascent to the top of the industry.
“She is wise enough to delegate more than she did in Year 1, for the sake of her own health,” he wrote. “And Nakase drives players only on their terms; she asks them how they like to be pushed and she pushes them that way.”
There is a specific reason Nakase prefers this approach and strategy.
“Why am I finding something? Why am I trying to guess?” she told Hamilton.
“Just tell me.”
Nakase, of course, has to be a willing, poised, effective listener and be receptive to implementing, if not as a rule, than most of what she learned from what she was told.
This boss has chosen to do it differently.
There is a legitimate question about the practicality of this process.
“I love how intentional this is and I think the message is important: ‘I want to know what makes you tick and I want to possibly modify how I interact with you because of it,’” says Erin Mittelstaedt, CEO at The FruitGuys, a family-owned farm-fresh fruit and vegetable delivery company.
“I think this would work best with smaller teams. For a team of more than 15 people, it would be harder for leadership to keep track of everyone’s motivators and individualize their approach. If 75 people want to be motivated in 60 different ways, that can quickly get complicated.”
She proposes an adjustment to make the approach easier to implement, if desired.
“I think there is a way to follow the ethos of this idea without explicitly asking everyone how they’d like to be motivated,” Mittelstaedt says.
“On a larger team, you could talk about what brings them together as a team rather than what motivates them individually.
“And on a smaller team, instead of asking someone what’s motivating to them, you could ask them about a time when they felt really successful. What gave them that feeling? That will help you understand what’s important to them.”
A professional whose work centers around understanding people in a workplace context explains her viewpoint.
“The approach the leader is taking can be beneficial for motivation and will work particularly well with smaller teams where there is time to hold those conversations and the ability to adapt for each employee,” says Phoebe Simmons, a researcher, chartered psychologist and the founder at the consultancy, What Matters Group, which uses psychological science to help organizations better understand their people and workplace cultures.
“Taking what I would call a ‘coaching approach’ to motivation enables the person to communicate their needs, feel heard and valued and provides a sense of autonomy over their work.”
She says this application doesn’t have to be limited to smaller-sized groups.
“With larger teams, the ability to adapt to everyone’s needs becomes more limited but some adaptation is still possible,” Simmons says.
“For example, they could choose from a range of approaches, incentives and consequences, instead of having completely free choice. Or the team could come to a shared approach that is developed in collaboration which would strengthen both motivation and a sense of connection within the team.”
There is confidence, from some, that Nakase’s practice could work at a greater scale.
“I know from my entrepreneurial journey that a similar approach worked when we had 10 people, then when we grew to 45 people and later, when I was overseeing 125 people,” says Feras Alhlou, an entrepreneur, startup coach, strategist and founder at Start Up With Feras.
“I was big on having a people-first culture and really including people in forming the vision and following up, asking them, what interests them? Some people want to work on complex projects. Some people want to learn new technology. Some people are going through a season in their lives when they want a lighter workload than usual.”
He does admit that it can be simpler when there are less employees.
“The idea here is to seek input from people,” Feras says. “When it’s a smaller organization, you talk to them, see them, have lunch with them and have Zoom calls every day when there are only 10 of you.
“But as you grow, you have to put mechanisms in place where your direct reports are talking to people and sharing that input with you, while also having some sort of mechanism for every person to reach out to you as CEO.”
Gabriel Shaoolian is in agreement with what Feras says about this scaling.
“Having more people to work with doesn’t inherently mean disregarding their needs in favor of efficiency or productivity,” says the founder and CEO at Digital Silk, a web design agency.
“The magic lies in developing and celebrating what’s different about each person, regardless of the team’s size. When you know their strengths and what triggers them to activate, it’s how you motivate them be proactive, learn and grow.”
Stephan Paschalides is even bolder in his answer.
“It works at any size. It just looks different,” says the founder at Now Plus One, where he designs insight immersions, which are field research programs that take corporate teams out of the office to learn from experts in other fields.
He explains.
“On a small team, you can sit down with each person. On a large team, the harder question is whether people will tell you the truth,” he argues.
“You don’t need a thousand one-on-ones. Listen to one person, act on it where others can see and people start talking.”
There is additional value that can be extracted from vocalized curiosity about what inspires your people to operate at their best.
“I think this is a great approach and encourages not only discussing how or what motivates your employees but also, how do they learn best?” says Katie Roland, the chief human resources officer at KCSA Strategic Communications.
“Are they auditory? Visual? Do they need to see it done before they can do it themselves?”
She does advise a word of caution.
“As with most things, the risk is in overdoing it,” Roland argues. “You don’t want a manager to feel like they must adapt their approach for every interaction with multiple employees. It is not feasible or fair to expect that. They would burn out.”
She does, however, recognize additional, higher value in using this process.
“Understanding an employee’s motivations and learning preferences can help you when stakes are high,” Roland says. “It can help you adapt your feedback and support to address their actual needs, rather than providing advice that won’t work. …
“When your team trusts you, you can lead them anywhere. Trust is the biggest benefit you get from this approach.”
That increasing trust may often come with more-consistent benefits.
“Asking and understanding your employees emotional motivations is what truly makes a team cohesive and effective,” says Sandy Gerber, an emotional Intelligence and communication trainer and an author at NEXT Impact Press.
“Once you understand which of the four primary drivers — Emotional Magnets — that person has: Safety, Achievement, Value or Experience — you can give them projects and tasks that align to those motivations and they will be super engaged and activated.”
This, she contends, drives quality of workplace relationships for the benefit of task accomplishment.
“By leading this way, you have a deeper connection with authentic and empathetic communication because you understand what that person needs to be happy in their role and within the team,” Gerber says.
It may be helpful to consider what risks, if any, accompany Nakase’s personalized approach to drive the individuals she leads and the collective performance.
“When you ask how someone prefers to be treated, you’d better be prepared to follow through,” Mittelstaedt warns. “If you ask the question and then do the opposite or ignore what you were told entirely, that’s worse than not asking at all.
“In those situations, it’s important to be transparent and have a conversation with the employee about why you can’t act on their preferences.”
Paschalides sees two, obvious, significant problems.
“First, people don’t always know what drives them,” he says.
He told a story of how, for a program for Sharpie, they went to “a gym with a high ledge over a foam pit. Nobody wanted to go near it. The coach started everyone on small, easy moves, the room started cheering and by the end people were jumping off the top. If he’d stuck to what they said they were comfortable with, nobody would have left the floor,” Paschalides says.
He then echoes what Mittelstaedt stated.
“The second risk is worse: asking for input and doing nothing with it. People notice and they stop telling you things.”
Simmons’ thinking is in alignment and she attaches a known problem to it.
“One potential risk, given the increasing rate of burnout, is that a person may not be fully aware of what motivational techniques would be best in the long term for their well-being,” she says.
“For example, they may identify tight deadlines as a good motivator for them but then find they are continually in a high state of stress, which may eventually impact their well-being.”
There is additional insight to weigh, Simmons recommends.
“Another thing to consider is that while we have different motivational preferences, we all have three basic psychological needs, as outlined by Self Determination Theory (Ryan and Deci, 2000), that motivate us,” she says.
“Autonomy, which refers to feeling you have a sense of control in your workplace; competence, which is the need to feel effective and succeed on challenges and tasks; and relatedness, which is the need to feel a sense of belonging and connection.”
That’s why Simmons asserts that “any adaptations to the workplace — and motivational techniques — should still ensure these three basic needs are met.”
Nakase’s personalization may not produce the desired results with all people.
“Incentive-based management has it’s downsides,” Shaoolian says. “Aside from it potentially producing temporary compliance, it can also introduce over-reliance on external rewards and erode interest in the work itself. Not to mention the level of transparency and fairness that all managers need to pay attention to.
“You can’t serve inconsistent recognition or show favoritism in any way. It needs to be consistent, transparent and explained respectfully.”
There is value that leaders are highly likely to notice and appreciate.
“You stop wasting time trying to manage everyone the same way,” Paschalides bluntly says. “Most leaders lead people the way they'd want to be led. Once you know what actually drives each person, you can stop guessing.”
He briefly elaborates.
“One employee loves public praise. Another finds it embarrassing. One needs clear limits and another needs room to run,” Paschalides points out. “When you get that right, people stop second-guessing you and get on with the work.”
While nothing may be guaranteed, the odds favor improvement.
“In theory, your team would become higher-performing. If someone feels highly motivated because you’re motivating them in exactly the way they want, they should do great work for you,” Mittelstaedt says.
“You’ll get to know your team better,” she adds. “Even if an employee isn’t sure what motivates them, you’ll learn a lot about them in the process of having that conversation. It also builds trust and rapport, showing employees that you care about them as individuals.”
Shaoolian says the culture should end up being appealing.
“It builds trust and creates a positive working environment,” he says.
“As a leader, you need to care about people as whole individuals and give them the autonomy of doing their jobs in the best way that they can. Asking them how they want to be motivated is certainly one way of doing it.
“You create the safety of inviting their input, showing your curiosity and responding constructively. People feel more inclined to share ideas, problems and mistakes earlier, which then improves learning and innovation.”
A feeling of respect and personalization can drive energy, positive mental health and commitment.
“It keeps the employees engaged, motivated, encouraged, loyal and driven to work to the collective goals because their own emotional needs are being met,” Gerber says.
That helps management’s interactions with them.
”The leader is enabled to communicate authentically — and at a deeper level from these discussions — and is effective at empowering and motivating the team to achieve their results,” Gerber says.
She has gained something valuable from what people experience with this practice.
“I've personally had employees follow me from company to company because I led them understanding their Emotional Magnets.”
Stephan PaschalidesFounderCurious what your team would find?
Bring the question on your team’s mind,
and we’ll suggest a few places that could answer it.




